Door comparisons
The four comparisons that decide most door projects are prehung versus slab, steel versus fiberglass, sliding versus French patio doors, and repair versus replace. Prehung fixes a bad frame; slab is cheaper but only works in a sound one. Steel costs less and resists force; fiberglass resists dents and rot with less upkeep.
Prehung vs. slab. This is a condition question, not a preference. Prehung includes a new frame, hinges and threshold, so it corrects an opening that is out of square or has rot. A slab reuses the existing frame and is meaningfully cheaper and faster. If you can push a thumbnail into the jamb, the answer is prehung.
Steel vs. fiberglass. Steel is generally the lower-cost, higher-strength option; fiberglass resists denting and rot and needs less upkeep. Both outlast wood in exposed positions on published lifespan estimates. Neither is universally correct - pick based on exposure, budget and how much the door's appearance matters.
Sliding vs. French patio doors. Sliders take no floor swing space and are usually cheaper; French doors give a wider clear opening and better looks but need room to swing and have more weather-sealing points. In a small room, a slider is often just the right answer.
Repair vs. replace. Default to repair for latching, sticking and draft complaints. Replace when there is rot in the frame or sill, a warped or delaminated slab, or an opening that has gone out of square. That framing is more useful than any percentage rule.
Choosing doors between the options
The judgement calls that decide the bill, before anyone quotes you.
- Test the frame before choosing prehung or slab Press the lower jamb and sill with your thumb, and check the gaps around the closed door for consistency. Uneven gaps mean the opening has moved.
- Compare quotes on the same scope A slab quote will always beat a prehung quote. Make sure you're not comparing two different projects and calling one a better deal.
- Weigh floor space for patio doors Measure the swing arc before choosing French doors. If it collides with furniture you actually use, the slider is the better door.
- Storm doors: check the main door first A storm door over a dark-colored, sun-exposed door can trap heat. Confirm the main door manufacturer's guidance before adding one.
All doors comparisons
Fiberglass vs Steel Doors
Prehung vs Slab Door
French vs Sliding Patio Doors
Wood vs Fiberglass Entry Door
Storm Door Worth It
Where these figures come from
Sources last checked
- Steel vs Fiberglass Entry Door: Buyer's Guide 2026 · retrieved 2026-07-25
- How Long Fiberglass Exterior Doors Last vs. Steel & Wood · retrieved 2026-07-25
- How to Fix Common Exterior Door Problems · retrieved 2026-07-25
You know more than the last homeowner they quoted.
That is worth something only while you are still choosing. Tell us what is going on and we will match you with a few doors pros whose licence and insurance we have already checked - free, no obligation.
Free · No pressure · Only your matched pros get your details