Electrical comparisons
The electrical comparisons that matter financially are narrow: subpanel versus service upgrade, targeted repair versus panel replacement, remediating older wiring versus a full rewire, and 100-amp versus 200-amp service. In each case the honest answer depends on a load calculation and an inspection of what you actually have, not on a rule of thumb.
Subpanel vs. service upgrade. If you are out of breaker slots but your service amperage is adequate, a subpanel at $400-$1,750 solves it, per This Old House. If the service itself cannot carry the load, a subpanel just moves the problem. The deciding document is a load calculation.
Repair vs. replace the panel. A single failed breaker is a $50-$100 part swap, per Inch Calculator. Full replacement makes sense when the panel is at capacity, is a model with documented failures, shows heat or corrosion damage, or parts are unobtainable. 'It's old' by itself is not a reason.
Remediate vs. rewire. With aluminum branch wiring, connection-level remediation at roughly $50-$75 per outlet is a very different number from a $12,000-$36,600 whole-house rewire, per HomeGuide. With knob-and-tube, rewiring is usually the realistic path, partly because many insurers treat it as a coverage issue.
100A vs. 200A. If you are already upgrading, the marginal cost of going to 200A is often modest relative to doing the job twice. This Old House puts 100-amp panel-plus-install at $800-$1,500 and 200-amp at $1,300-$3,000. Decide against your future loads - EV, heat pump, induction range, ADU - not just today's.
Choosing electrical between the options
The judgement calls that decide the bill, before anyone quotes you.
- Make the load calculation the tiebreaker Every comparison here resolves to the same document. Ask for it. A contractor unwilling to produce one is guessing.
- Price the do-it-twice scenario Ask each bidder what it would cost to come back and upsize later. That number usually makes the right choice obvious.
- Get repair and replace priced by the same contractor If a contractor will only quote the replacement, ask them to also quote the repair and explain in writing why it is insufficient.
- Factor insurance into the comparison Some conditions - knob-and-tube in particular - affect insurability. Call your carrier before you choose, because it can flip the math.
- Do not compare on price alone Confirm all bids include the same scope: permit, inspection, service-entrance work, and wall repair. Otherwise you are comparing different jobs.
All electrical comparisons
Panel Upgrade vs Full Rewire
AFCI vs GFCI
Copper vs Aluminum Wiring
Fuse Box vs Breaker Panel
DIY Electrical vs Licensed Electrician
200 Amp vs 100 Amp Service
Smart Panel vs Traditional Panel
Where these figures come from
Sources last checked
- This Old House - What Is the Cost to Upgrade an Electrical Panel? · retrieved 2026-07-25
- Inch Calculator - Cost to Upgrade Electrical Panel, 2026 Price Guide · retrieved 2026-07-25
- HomeGuide - Cost to Replace Knob and Tube Wiring (2026) · retrieved 2026-07-25
You know more than the last homeowner they quoted.
That is worth something only while you are still choosing. Tell us what is going on and we will match you with a few electrical pros whose licence and insurance we have already checked - free, no obligation.
Free · No pressure · Only your matched pros get your details