Flooring comparisons
For wet or below-grade rooms, vinyl and tile beat any wood product. For long-term value in dry living space, solid hardwood at $9-$23 per square foot installed outlasts everything else - properly maintained wood floors last 50 years or more. For budget, luxury vinyl plank at $3-$11 per square foot installed is hard to beat. And if you already have sound hardwood, refinishing at $3-$8 per square foot beats replacing at $6-$12.
Vinyl plank vs laminate. Both are floating floors that mimic wood. Vinyl plank is waterproof and installs at $3-$11 per square foot. Laminate is priced across a wide band - a 1,000-square-foot laminate job runs roughly $4,118-$20,119 all in - and does not handle standing water the same way. In kitchens, baths, laundries and basements, vinyl is the safer pick.
Engineered vs solid hardwood. Engineered runs $8-$14 per square foot installed, solid runs $9-$23. Engineered handles slabs and humidity swings better. Solid can be refinished many times and lasts 50 years or more. If you're flooring a slab-on-grade house, this comparison is already decided for you.
Refinish vs replace. Refinishing runs $3-$8 per square foot, with a national average around $1,200 for a typical job and a usual range of $800-$1,600. New hardwood runs $6-$12 per square foot installed before tear-out and prep. If the existing boards are sound and thick enough, refinishing is the better trade almost every time. A screen-and-recoat, at $1-$2.50 per square foot, is cheaper still when the wear is only in the finish.
Carpet vs hard surface. Carpet averages $7.47 per square foot installed and is warmer and quieter, but it wears visibly and cannot be refreshed. Hard surface costs more up front in most rooms and lasts longer. Bedrooms are the one place where carpet still routinely wins on comfort per dollar.
Choosing flooring between the options
The judgement calls that decide the bill, before anyone quotes you.
- Let the room decide, not the showroom Moisture and traffic pick the material. Color and finish are the part where taste belongs.
- Compare installed costs, never material costs Tile looks competitive on material and expensive on labor. Vinyl is the reverse. Only the installed number is comparable.
- Count the refinishes you'll get Solid hardwood can be sanded repeatedly. Engineered wood and vinyl cannot. Over 30 years that changes the math more than the purchase price does.
- Don't mix too many materials on one level Every material change needs a transition strip at $10-$40 and creates a trip edge and a dirt line. Fewer transitions look better and cost less.
- Screen-and-recoat before you commit to a full sand At $1-$2.50 per square foot it's the cheapest test of whether your floor really needs anything more.
All flooring comparisons
Hardwood vs LVP
Laminate vs LVP
Engineered vs Solid Hardwood
Tile vs LVP Bathroom
Carpet vs Hard Floors
Bamboo vs Hardwood
SPC vs WPC Vinyl
DIY Flooring vs Pro Install
Refinish vs Replace Hardwood
Where these figures come from
Sources last checked
- Fixr - Hardwood Floor Installation Cost · retrieved 2026-07-26
- Fixr - Hardwood Floor Refinishing Cost · retrieved 2026-07-26
- Fixr - Vinyl Plank Flooring Cost · retrieved 2026-07-26
- Fixr - Carpet Installation Cost · retrieved 2026-07-26
- This Old House - Flooring Cost Guide (laminate totals) · retrieved 2026-07-26
You know more than the last homeowner they quoted.
That is worth something only while you are still choosing. Tell us what is going on and we will match you with a few flooring pros whose licence and insurance we have already checked - free, no obligation.
Free · No pressure · Only your matched pros get your details