HomeMatchup
Home Warranty · Brands

Home warranty companies

Compare home warranty companies on their actual contracts, not their marketing or star ratings. Request the full sample agreement from each, then compare five things side by side: the exclusions list, the per-item and aggregate caps, the service call fee (typically $75 to $125), the renewal price, and the dispute resolution clause.

We do not summarize any specific company's terms here, on purpose. Contract language differs by company, by plan, and by state, and it changes. Any secondhand summary of a provider's coverage is out of date the moment a form is revised. Get the current sample contract for your state and your plan, in writing, before you pay.

Ratings and review sites are weak evidence. Many home warranty comparison sites earn commissions on referrals. That does not make them useless, but it means their rankings are not independent evaluations. Treat the contract as the evidence and the ranking as an opinion.

Check the regulator, not just the reviews. These contracts are regulated at the state level, and which agency depends on the state — insurance department, real estate commission or consumer protection body. Look the company up with your state's regulator, and check whether it's licensed to sell in your state at all. If you're unsure which agency applies, most state attorney general offices publish a complaint referral process that will route you.

Compare on price too, but last. Plans span roughly $300 to $1,000 a year with $75 to $125 service fees. A cheaper premium paired with a lower coverage cap is not a saving. Price is the tiebreaker after the contract comparison, not the starting point.

How to choose

Request the full contract from every provider
Same plan level, same state. Then compare the documents, not the websites.
Verify licensing with your state regulator
Which agency regulates these contracts varies by state. Confirm the company is authorized to sell where you live.
Treat commission-funded rankings as opinion
Many comparison sites are paid on referrals. Read the contract yourself.
Compare caps before premiums
A $400 plan with a low cap can cost more in practice than a $700 plan with a realistic one.
Ask for the renewal price in writing
First-year pricing is a promotion. Renewal is the price you'll actually pay for years.
0 of 7 live

All home warranty brands

American Home Shield

Choice Home Warranty

First American

Liberty Home Guard

Select Home Warranty

Cinch

2 10 Home Buyers Warranty

FAQ

Home Warranty brands — common questions

Still have a question? Talk to our team →

There isn't a universal answer, and any site that gives you one quickly may be earning a referral fee. Compare full sample contracts for your state — exclusions, caps, service fee, renewal price and dispute clause.
Treat them as a starting point. Many are compensated for referrals. The contract document is the only authoritative statement of what a company will do.
Contact your state's regulating agency. Which one it is varies by state; your state attorney general's consumer complaint referral resources can identify the right one.
Not necessarily, but a low premium often comes with lower caps. Plans run roughly $300 to $1,000 a year — compare what each pays out, not just what each charges.
Sources

Where these figures come from

You know more than the last homeowner they quoted.

That is worth something only while you are still choosing. Tell us what is going on and we will match you with a few home warranty pros whose licence and insurance we have already checked — free, no obligation.

Get matched free

Free · No pressure · We never sell your details

(866) 582-8523 Get my free quote