Real reviews from real finished jobs.
A review is only worth reading if you know it came from someone who actually paid for the work. Here is the standard we hold ours to - collected after a completed job, tied to a real match, never bought, never edited by the pro, and never removable because the pro asked.
HomeMatchup only counts reviews from real homeowners after a real, finished HomeMatchup job. There are no anonymous web reviews, no fake reviews, and no paid placements. We rank roofers by their rating, recent verified work, warranty follow-through, and how they fix problems. No roofer can pay to rank higher.
Where do HomeMatchup reviews come from?
From you - after the job is done. Every review is tied to a real, completed HomeMatchup job. That's the only way one counts.
Real, finished jobs only
A review only counts after the roofer did the work and you saw it done. No job, no review. It's that simple.
Tied to a real homeowner
Every review comes from the homeowner we matched. No anonymous strangers. No reviews bought from a list.
No anonymous web reviews
We don't pull star ratings from random sites. Those can be faked or bought. We only trust reviews we can stand behind.
How does HomeMatchup rank roofers?
We weigh real work over flashy words. Here's what we measure - and why it keeps you safe.
| Factor | What we measure | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | The star score from real homeowners after a finished job. | It shows how people felt once the work was done - not before. |
| Recent verified jobs | How many real HomeMatchup jobs they've finished lately. | A roofer doing good work now is safer than one coasting on old praise. |
| Warranty follow-through | Do they honor the written warranty when something needs a fix? | A warranty only helps you if the roofer actually shows up for it. |
| Responsiveness | How fast they answer and show up for matched homeowners. | A leak can't wait. Fast, steady pros keep your home dry. |
| Complaint resolution | When a job goes sideways, how well they make it right. | Good roofers fix problems. How they handle a bad day tells you a lot. |
See the full 6-point trust check in how we verify roofers →
What kinds of reviews do you reject?
Anything that could trick you out. If it isn't real and earned, it doesn't count.
Fake reviews
Made-up praise, bot reviews, friends-and-family puffery. None of it counts. We check the job is real first.
Paid placements
No roofer can pay for a better rating or a higher spot. You can't buy your way to the top here.
Reviews with no real job
If there's no finished HomeMatchup job behind it, it doesn't count. No job, no review - every time.
No pay-to-rank. Ever.
A roofer can't buy a higher rank, a better rating, or a top spot. Ranking is earned by real work and real reviews - full stop. We'd rather lose a paying roofer than mislead you.
The job will still be there next month.
It will just cost more, and you will be choosing in a hurry - which is how most people end up with the contractor they regret. Getting matched takes about a minute and costs nothing.
Free • No obligation • Licence & insurance verified