Roofing services fall into four groups: inspection and diagnosis, targeted repair, full replacement (tear-off and re-roof), and the trim work around the roof - flashing, vents, drip edge and gutters. Most homeowners only ever need two of these: an honest inspection, and either a repair or a replacement.
The single most useful thing to know is that repair and replacement are different businesses. A repair fixes a specific failure - a lifted shingle, cracked flashing at a chimney, a nail pop that turned into a leak. A replacement strips the roof to the deck and starts again. A contractor who only ever quotes replacements is not necessarily dishonest, but you should get a second opinion before signing.
Age and extent decide it. If the roof is well inside its expected life and the damage is confined to one area, repair. Fixr puts typical asphalt shingle life at 20-30 years, metal at 50-70, clay and concrete tile at up to 100 years and slate at up to 150. If your asphalt roof is 22 years old and leaking in three places, you are paying twice if you patch it.
Watch out for services sold as add-ons that are really part of the job. Tear-off and disposal, underlayment, drip edge and new flashing at every penetration should all be line items on a replacement quote. If a quote is one number with no breakdown, ask for the breakdown before you compare it to anything.
Each one covers what the job involves, what moves the price, and when it is the wrong call.
A full tear-off and new roof, done right the first time - most homes run $6,000-$40,000 installed.
Leaks, missing shingles, and flashing fixes - most repairs run $400-$2,500.
Standing seam and metal shingle roofs that last 40-70 years.
Asphalt shingles - the most popular roof in America, installed by vetted pros.
TPO, EPDM, and modified bitumen for flat and low-slope roofs.
TPO, EPDM, PVC and modified bitumen - membrane choice, fall correction and ponding.
Hail and wind damage help - inspection, documentation, and the insurance claim.
Gutter replacement and guards that protect your roofline and foundation.
A pro inspection before you buy, sell, or file a claim.
A brand-new roof installed right - new builds, additions, and material switches.
Find the real source and seal it - most leak repairs run $150-$1,500.
Fast, same-day tarping and repair when water is pouring in.
Free hail check, claim documentation, and a lasting fix - no storm-chasers.
Lifted and missing shingles fixed fast, with insurance help.
Get the roof your policy already owes you - documented and adjuster-ready.
A yearly tune-up that adds years to your roof - most run $150-$600.
Safe soft-wash moss and algae removal - most jobs run $300-$1,200.
Seamless gutters sized to your home - most installs run $1,000-$6,000.
Reseal, re-hang, and unclog sagging or leaking gutters - $150-$800.
Balanced attic airflow that lowers bills and helps your roof last - $300-$2,500.
Add natural light without the leaks - most skylights run $1,000-$3,500.
Stop leaks around the chimney with new, watertight flashing - $300-$1,500.
Safe steam removal that stops winter leaks - most jobs run $400-$1,500.
TPO, EPDM, and flat commercial systems - about $5-$15 per sq ft installed.
Coatings, metal roof-overs, and replacements for manufactured homes - $1,500-$8,000.
A shingle overlay when your roof qualifies - $4,500-$14,000, less than a tear-off.
Leaf protection so you stop cleaning gutters - most systems run $500-$3,500.
Repair or replace the roof-edge boards that hold gutters and seal your eaves - $600-$3,500.
Seal and extend a flat or metal roof and reflect heat - $1,000-$4,500.
The judgement calls that decide the bill, before anyone quotes you.
Ask for the roof measurement, not your house size
Roofs are priced by roofing squares (100 sq ft of roof surface). A 2,000 sq ft house usually has considerably more than 2,000 sq ft of roof once pitch and overhangs are counted. Any quote should state the square count it is based on.
Get the tear-off scope in writing
Fixr puts tear-off and disposal at roughly $50-$150 per square. A quote that omits it, or quietly assumes an overlay on top of your old shingles, is not comparable to one that includes it.
Insist on new flashing
Flashing at chimneys, valleys and walls is where most leaks start. Reusing old flashing on a new roof saves the contractor a few hundred dollars and costs you the roof's watertightness.
Separate the emergency from the repair
A tarp at 9pm and a proper repair are two different visits. Pay for the tarp, then get the repair quoted in daylight by more than one company.
Three written quotes, same scope
Give each contractor the same brief. If one quote is dramatically lower, it is usually missing tear-off, underlayment or flashing - not offering a better deal.
Most people booking roofing work are buying a diagnosis, not a job - and the trade you pick decides what diagnosis you get. Book the wrong specialist and you pay a call-out fee to be told it is somebody else's problem.
HomeMatchup is not a roofing contractor. We don't sell equipment, we don't quote jobs and we never show up at your house. What we do is one thing: put your job in front of the local pros who are licensed, insured and actually take work like yours - so you're choosing between vetted options instead of gambling on whoever answers the phone first.
Your ZIP and a short description. About 60 seconds, and no, you don't need to know what the work should cost - that's the part we're helping with.
We route it to pros who work your area and hold the licence the job legally requires. You stop being the person calling six numbers and leaving five voicemails.
Quotes come to you. Compare them against the checklist further down this page, then hire whoever you want - or nobody. There's no fee and no obligation either way.
Free to you · No obligation to hire · Only your matched pros get your details · How we vet pros
That is worth something only while you are still choosing. Tell us what is going on and we will match you with a few roofing pros whose licence and insurance we have already checked - free, no obligation.

Twenty years on and around home improvement work. Reads our guides for the things that are technically true and practically wrong.
Every guide on this site is written by a member of our team and checked by someone else before it publishes, and every figure carries the source and the date we pulled it. Found a number that looks off? Tell us - corrections are the cheapest quality control we have.