Free roofing tool

Repair or replace your roof?

Not sure whether to patch your roof or replace it? Here’s how to decide — and get a free pro opinion.

The repair-or-replace call comes down to your roof’s age, how widespread the damage is, and how long you plan to stay. Here’s the quick guide — then get a free, honest inspection from a vetted local pro.

Get a free pro opinion

A rule of thumb — an honest inspection from a vetted pro gives you the real answer.

Get a real quote from a vetted pro

Repair or replace — the quick guide

Repair if: the roof is under 15 years old, the damage is in one spot, and the rest of the roof is sound. A repair runs $400–$2,800.

Replace if: the roof is past 80% of its rated life, you’re patching it every storm season, shingles are curling or bald across the roof, or the decking is sagging. See repair vs. replace and signs you need a new roof.

When you’re on the fence, a vetted pro gives an honest inspection — not a sales pitch.

Cost ranges reflect 2026 U.S. installed prices (BLS producer/labor data, Remodeling Cost vs. Value, and manufacturer pricing). Your real price depends on your roof, region, and pro — see the full cost guide.

FAQ

Repair or Replace Quiz questions

Want a real number? Get matched with a vetted local pro →

Repair if the roof is young and the damage is local; replace if it is old, leaks keep coming back, or the decking sags. When unsure, get an honest inspection from a vetted pro.
If your roof is past about 80% of its rated life (roughly 20 years for asphalt) and shingles are curling or bald across the whole roof, repairs only buy a little time — replacement usually costs less over time.
A repair ($400–$2,800) is cheaper up front. But if you are patching an old roof every season, those repairs add up — and a failing roof risks costly water damage. Replacement can be the cheaper long-term move.
It can, if a covered event like hail or a storm caused the damage. Insurance won’t pay for a roof that simply wore out. A vetted pro documents storm damage so you can file.

Your roof can’t wait. Let’s get it done right.

Get matched with a trusted local pro today. Free. No pressure. Takes 60 seconds.

Free • No pressure • Licensed & insured pros

(888) 555-0147 Get my free quote